|
Post by lucifer on Jun 11, 2009 19:49:03 GMT
12 minutes and counting till Night begins.
|
|
|
Post by lucifer on Jun 11, 2009 20:18:20 GMT
Hmm. Well, we lost Total Ulla, but she went out with maximum damage (nice job, TU, thanks). I tried to save you, but it didn't stick. Hopefully Special Ed will be here shortly.
PCM, welcome to the game. Nice job toDay with the soft AoN smear.
Night 1: PreCambrianMollusc Night 2: Total Ulla RIP Night 3: Special Ed Night 4: sublight
Here's my notes...
Pod People and Recurits Winston Smith PreCambrianMollusc special ed (Night 3 Recruit, possible power role) sublight (Night 4 Recruit, possible power role)
Confirmed Power Roles Vox Psychoanalyst AngelOfTheNorth Town Drunk
Remaining Pool for Sheriff hunting AllWalker Zsofia cowgirl Rabid Renaissance Myrnalene (lurking, 1 post toDay for Ulla) paulwhoisaghost (lurking, 1 post toDay)
Dead One and only Wanderers--VT (lynch) Angel of the North--VT (lynch) AllWalker--VT (NK) special ed--VT (NK) Total Ulla Pod (NK)
|
|
|
Post by lucifer on Jun 11, 2009 20:22:44 GMT
AngelOfTheNorth suggested that 'all the roles had been revealed', but I guess I'm dense because for the life of me I can't figure out who Sheriff, Mad Scientist and Nosy Reporter are. I have a hunch that Special Ed is the Nosy Reporter - we'll find out soon enough. It would be really awesome if he is the Sheriff. I think that would be an almost guaranteed win for us.
I'm not all that concerned with finding the Mad Scientist. After toMorrow night, the role becomes null and void, like the Nosy Reporter and the Town Drunk.
|
|
|
Post by lucifer on Jun 11, 2009 20:28:04 GMT
So, the question is: Do we go after Vox, or try our luck in the remaining pool? The former is a big WIFOM dilemma with the Sheriff out there. I think Angel is of little threat because sublight is the only recruit out there for her to detect, and by an amazing stroke of luck he's kept quiet and avoided contreversy.
|
|
|
Post by lucifer on Jun 11, 2009 20:30:45 GMT
Rab Ren continues to ping my radar. Unless you've seen something I'm missing, she may be the best potential candidate for night kill of the remaining pool of unknowns.
|
|
|
Post by lucifer on Jun 11, 2009 20:56:52 GMT
cowgirl and RabRen are still online, everyone else is offline. Does it mean anything? Probably not. Damn. This suspense is killing me...
|
|
pcm
New Member
Posts: 34
|
Post by pcm on Jun 11, 2009 23:14:39 GMT
LuciferSmith - hi - I hope to hell no one reds the forbidden thread, I was with Special ed calling for ullas head straight off the bat after her claim. Ulla - sorry to see you go. Yes agree, Rab Ren could be something - Her vote shifting seamed pretty cagey - although she could well be deliberately trying to appear coy. Going to go back and look at the unvotes of vox etc when Ulla claimed. Tomorrow I think there will be a lot of looking at the order in which the unvotes came after special eds case (heheh what more can you ask for the man who lead the lynch didn't know he would shortly be scum, he has townie cred. Mind you if he was not a recruit there could be some headway in smudging him over his too quick to spot the Ulla mistake and he pursued it, so maybe he is the MPP safely busing one of his own and he appeared to know too much. Well something like that - could even be some mileage in it for some scum on scum infighting out there.) Ok I don't see much pattern in the vote un vote so we should be able to discuss that at length during the day. As for target - right now - yeah agree we need to talk sheriff hunting or the NR, tas you say he Town Drunk will be less and less useful to town by tomorrow, the PA is the worry. more in a bit - and stay out the medicine cabinet
|
|
pcm
New Member
Posts: 34
|
Post by pcm on Jun 11, 2009 23:40:13 GMT
Vox wise - he needs to die - but too risky with the sheriff out there. Although all we need to do is keep you alive until endgame and you are safe from Vox, so Vox killing is not the biggest deal in the world, any confirmable power role will do.
As an entirely random thought, what happens if it comes to a three way between you, the sherrif and another VT and the VT gets lynched, you can't night kill the Sheriff and the day lynch is a tie, I guess you just go to the bar and drink.
|
|
julie
New Member
Posts: 27
|
Post by julie on Jun 12, 2009 2:39:54 GMT
The Recruitment has been successful. Special ed has been notified and given the link.
|
|
pcm
New Member
Posts: 34
|
Post by pcm on Jun 12, 2009 3:28:02 GMT
cool - greetings special ed
|
|
pcm
New Member
Posts: 34
|
Post by pcm on Jun 12, 2009 7:52:11 GMT
OK Rab ren is not the NR. She was suggesting to get pedescribe on Vox couch, and Pedscribe was subbed by AON who turned out to be the Town Drunk. If Rab Ren was the NR she would know pedscribe was the TD. Later after Specials Ed post point Ullas slip , she wondered why people were voting for Vox as if Speical Eds post didnt exist, then later votes for vox over ulla based on ulla language claim. This happened when things were fairly tight vote wise, so I don;t see it as a deceptive vote. Basically Rab ren doesn't know who TU is. There may be a smudgy case against Rab ren - more of that later
Cowgirl was also quick off the mark, All Walker and Sublight are not the NR either Paulwhoisaghost and Zofia were all voting early for vox after Ulla claim - really don,t see any of them helping out Special ed with his claim.
Myralene after not much posting is in with a one liner saying she believes Vox and votes for Ulla After that Special makes everything clear to town and the big vote swing happens I say Myralene is the NR - Did I miss anyone off the list I think we should kill her - the power of confirming the rest is just too big. The Sherrif and Mad scintist roles are not easily confirmable so can be false claimed Now if the Sheriff does the same read through he/she may see the same thing. Question is will they be too busy to do that as they are worrying about wifoming us with vox/AON protection
If I am right the sherrif pool is Sublight (recruit) AllWalker Zsofia cowgirl Rabid Renaissance paulwhoisaghost (lurking, 1 post toDay)
|
|
pcm
New Member
Posts: 34
|
Post by pcm on Jun 12, 2009 8:04:36 GMT
Smudgy RabRen case She suggested getting Pedscribe on the couch as he had been lurking since day one The only one with reason to lurk on day one is the MPP as others would not know they were scum yet, Rab Ren as scum knows this and also knows the MPP (which she knows Pedescibe isn't) would come up vanilla. So at the time TU is trying to direct the investigation onto someone who she know is not scum, but the investigation wont proove anything anyway. A scummy rab ren woudl say - ahhh well Pedescribe could be the MPP anyway
Later she criticises people (notable Cow and Paul as they voted TU after SpecEd post, although not explicitly mentioned) for not paying attention to Specials Eds pointing out of TUs lie and there being no discussion of it. However She herself then votes for Vox with out further analysis of special eds post , based on trusting Ulla as a player.
So bit convoluted but in essence it trying to direct teh night investigation with bad reasoning and 'do as I say not as I do' over specials eds analysis. As I said bit smudgy and a bit high risk, and if we don't have a result from vox or AOn to work onas town it could be something to whip out at a later date Right - its friday and it is beer o'clock
|
|
|
Post by lucifer on Jun 12, 2009 9:55:06 GMT
good anaysis pcm. i'll post more when i get to the office.
Ihope we hear from Ed. TU never showed up for discussion last Night. She did well with her claim but I would have liked to have heard her thoughts on who's who
|
|
pcm
New Member
Posts: 34
|
Post by pcm on Jun 12, 2009 10:26:45 GMT
Lucifer - Please kick holes in it
I think we need a plan for claiming as one of us may get identified If vox gets me I think I'll claim Sheriff - if we get the NR with a Myralene kill, and throw some more crap vox way over being a turned PA who shopped Ulla for credibility If AON picks Sublight then I guess we can faff around questioning AON credibility as we can't appear to be too eager to accept her result as that would imply we know for sure she is telling the truth. Can't go overboard though and we will just have to get behind the lynch to test AON. Sucks but there we go.
|
|
|
Post by lucifer on Jun 12, 2009 10:39:15 GMT
i will, when i'm in front of a proper browser with multiple windows.
|
|